Skip to content

Uncategorized

Prop Permanence (Coffee Cup Tracker)

Flags objects that characters pick up but never put down within a scene.

What It Does

Tracks pickup verbs (grabbed, took, lifted) and release verbs (dropped, set, placed) per scene. When a character picks up an object but the scene ends without a corresponding release, the diagnostic fires.

Why It Matters

Objects don't vanish from characters' hands. If a character grabs a sword and then has a two-page conversation, they're still holding it. Experienced editors call this the "coffee cup problem" — characters pick up coffee at the start of a scene and it disappears into narrative limbo.

What Gets Flagged

Severity Example Why Suggested Revision
Hint "She grabbed the lantern." (never released) Object held indefinitely Add "She set the lantern on the table."

Configuration

No configuration options.

Technical Details

  • Source: prose-craft
  • Scope: Scene-level
  • Method: Pickup/release verb + object noun tracking with 4-token lookahead